The shirt of a teenage girl found in the wheel well of an abandoned van leads to a cold case from 1998, when a 15-year-old Carrie Swett, was assaulted and left for dead in the park. The van turns out to be registered to the janitor who worked at the girl's high school. The janitor claims the van broke down and he abandoned it, but he knew of Carrie and her reputation for being loose. He tells the detectives they should check with one of her "boyfriends", the captain of the baseball team. The baseball captain admits to using the girl for sex but not to killing her. But the real story begins to unfold when the detectives discover the girl was trying to change by joining a virginity club to "revirginize" herself. However, every member of the group turned out to be far from virginal, with their own dirty little secrets to keep. The group believed Carrie would corrupt them with her "wicked ways," making them face who they really were. In order to keep their secrets they decided to lure Carrie out to the woods and stone her to death. Fortunately, the cold case team is able to bring the culprits to justice.