Tobey Maguire Awards

Academy of Science Fiction, Fantasy & Horror Films, USA

2005

Won Saturn Award
category Best Actor for Spider-Man 2 (2004)

2003

Got nomination for Saturn Award
category Best Actor for Spider-Man (2002)

1999

Won Saturn Award
category Best Performance by a Younger Actor/Actress for Pleasantville (1998)

Empire Awards, UK

2005

Got nomination for Empire Award
category Best Actor for Spider-Man 2 (2004)

MTV Movie Awards

2008

Got nomination for MTV Movie Award
category Best Fight for Spider-Man 3 (2007)
shared with James Franco

2003

Won MTV Movie Award
category Best Kiss for Spider-Man (2002)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

2003

Got nomination for MTV Movie Award
category Best Male Performance for Spider-Man (2002)

Nickelodeon Kids' Choice Awards

2005

Got nomination for Blimp Award
category Favorite Movie Actor for Spider-Man 2 (2004)

2003

Got nomination for Blimp Award
category Favorite Male Butt Kicker for Spider-Man (2002)

People's Choice Awards, USA

2008

Got nomination for People's Choice Award
category Favorite on Screen Match Up for Spider-Man 3 (2007)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

2005

Got nomination for People's Choice Award
category Favorite Male Action Movie Star

2005

Got nomination for People's Choice Award
category Favorite On-Screen Chemistry for Spider-Man 2 (2004)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

Scream Awards

2007

Won Scream Award
category Best Superhero for Spider-Man 3 (2007)

Screen Actors Guild Awards

2004

Got nomination for Actor Award
category Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture for Seabiscuit (2003)
shared with Elizabeth Banks; Chris Cooper; William H. Macy

2000

Got nomination for Actor Award
category Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Theatrical Motion Picture for The Cider House Rules (1999)
shared with Erykah Badu; Michael Caine; Charlize Theron

Teen Choice Awards

2007

Got nomination for Teen Choice Award
category Choice Movie Actor: Action Adventure for Spider-Man 3 (2007)

2007

Got nomination for Teen Choice Award
category Choice Movie: Liplock for Spider-Man 3 (2007)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

2007

Got nomination for Teen Choice Award
category Choice Movie: Dance for Spider-Man 3 (2007)

2007

Got nomination for Teen Choice Award
category Choice Movie: Rumble (Spider-Man & New Goblin vs. Venom & Sandman) for Spider-Man 3 (2007)
shared with James Franco; Topher Grace; Thomas Haden Church

2002

Won Teen Choice Award
category Film - Choice Actor, Drama/Action Adventure for Spider-Man (2002)

2002

Won Teen Choice Award
category Film - Choice Lip Lock for Spider-Man (2002)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

2002

Got nomination for Teen Choice Award
category Film - Choice Chemistry for Spider-Man (2002)
shared with Kirsten Dunst

Toronto Film Critics Association Awards

2000

Won TFCA Award
category Best Supporting Performance, Male for Wonder Boys (2000)

Young Artist Awards

1993

Got nomination for Young Artist Award
category Best Young Actor in a New Television Series for Great Scott! (1992) (TV)