Michael Pena Awards

ALMA Awards

2011

Got nomination for ALMA Award
category Favorite Movie Actor for Battle: Los Angeles (2011)

2007

Got nomination for ALMA Award
category Outstanding Actor - Motion Picture for World Trade Center (2006)

2007

Got nomination for ALMA Award
category Outstanding Actor - Television Series, Mini-Series or Television Movie for Walkout (2006) (TV Movie)

2006

Won ALMA Award
category Outstanding Actor in a Motion Picture for Crash (2004)

Black Reel Awards

2007

Won Black Reel
category Network/Cable - Best Supporting Actor for Walkout (2006) (TV Movie)

Gotham Awards

2005

Got nomination for Gotham Best Ensemble Cast
for Crash (2004)
shared with Sandra Bullock; Matt Dillon; Thandie Newton

Imagen Foundation Awards

2006

Won Imagen Award
category Best Actor - Television for Walkout (2006) (TV Movie)