Audrey starts private pilates sessions at home and Jeff is thrilled when the workouts increase Audrey's sex drive. However, Jeff is quickly thrown when he learns Audrey's instructor is a good-looking young guy, and Jeff proceeds to fire him. Meanwhile, Jen is embarrassed when Adam breaks out his college letterman jacket and she discovers Adam was the captain of the cheerleading squad, not the football team as she'd always assumed. Things get even more embarrassing for Jen when a proud Adam insists on bragging about his cheerleading days to the guys. At the same time, Timmy and Russell fight over the affections of Beth, the new waitress at the diner.