Episode PremiereMarch 01, 2008
Show Period2007 - 2012
Production CompanySchneider's Bakery, Nickelodeon
Carly gives Sam a special T-shirt as a present on their fifth year anniversary of being best friends. Sam then trades it for Cuttlefish concert tickets for Carly and herself which abruptly starts a fight between them. Freddie believes this will badly effect iCarly, so he tries to let viewers decide who's right. Meanwhile, Spencer builds an automatic fish feeder with useless results.