Terri admits to her sister that she is hiding her fake pregnancy from Will because she's afraid he will leave her.
While rehearsing a lip synch and dance with Tina and Brittany to Single Ladies, Kurt is startled when his macho father Burt catches him. He lies and says he's wearing a unitard because he's practicing for his job as place kicker on the football team. Kurt enlists Finn for help, and Kurt "auditions" for the team. Unfortunately, he can only do it in the middle of his choreography to Single Ladies. Coach Tanaka doesn't care because Kurt is a place kicking prodigy.
Rachel is upset that a solo was given to Tina instead of her. This provides an opening for Sue, who blackmails Principal Figgins to hire Sandy Ryerson back at McKinley. She makes Sandy's first order of business to cast Rachel in the new musical so that she will quit glee club. Rachel plans to balance both.
Quinn tells Finn that she is pregnant, even though they never had sex. She convinces him that his sperm swam in a hot tub while they were wearing swimsuits. Finn confides in Will about his dilemma.
After Will tells Terri about the teen's pregnancy, Terri approaches Quinn. She wants to help the girl, but what are Terri's ulterior motives?
Since Quinn wants to keep the baby, Finn needs a football scholarship. He has Will teach the football players how to dance to improve their coordination.
After Puck learns that Quinn is pregnant, he confronts her. Puck knows it's his baby.
The team's new dancing skills and Kurt's kicking help McKinley win the football game. Burt is proud of his son.
Finn offers his support to Quinn. He wants to be a good father to their child. Seeing the two lovebirds together makes Puck jealous.
Kurt comes out about being gay to his father. "I've known since you were three," Burt confesses calmly. He tells Kurt he loves him.
Puck and two other football players join the glee club. Will refuses to give Rachel the solo he promised to Tina. So Rachel quits and turns to Sandy's musical exclusively.