Michael, Sam, Fiona, and Jesse regroup after having Barrett's list stolen by Brennen, an old enemy. Brennen approaches Michael with a deal Brennen feels is a win-win: by eliminating the people on Barrett's list, Brennen gets to turn a quick profit, and Michael gets to take out some of the people responsible for his Burn Notice. Brennen gives Michael the name of the first target that needs to be eliminated. When Michael refuses, Brennen brings in another familiar face to keep Michael in line. Michael's old mentor, "Dead" Larry. Michael must outsmart his two most worthy adversaries in order to get Barrett's list back.