Alan Shore is called upon by ex-flame Phoebe Prentice (Ally Walker, Profiler, Tell Me You Love Me) to prove her husband's innocence in the murder of a nurse. But deep down, Alan's unrequited love for Phoebe makes him hope that her husband is guilty so that they can rekindle their relationship. Brenda Strong (Desperate Housewives) guest stars as presiding Judge Judy Beacon.