Audrey pressures Jeff to tell her 5 things he likes about her as a person and he struggles with this task. He attempts to fulfill her request using lines from movies, leaving her disappointed. After numerous failed attempts, she lets him off the hook and seeing how upset she is, he is finally able to express how he feels. Meanwhile, Russell sets Timmy up to embarrass himself in an effort to impress a girl. Knowing she likes musicians, he teaches him a song to play on guitar for her. Timmy performs the song at a party and is so terrible, Russell goes from enjoying his joke to feeling bad for Timmy and joins him on stage to help minimize the damage. In addition, Adam and Jen are surprised to discover how much money Jeff and Audrey have saved when they accidentally receive their financial statement in the mail.