Jeff is stunned to learn that his new friend from the gym, Brad, is gay. Prior to learning this, Jeff had agreed to meet Brad and some friends at a local bar to watch a ball game. Now thinking that he'll have nothing in common with Brad, Jeff decides to skip it, but Audrey convinces him he should go. Once at the bar Jeff is so self conscious of saying something inappropriate that he panics and ends up stammering like an idiot. However, once he discovers that Brad and his husband share the same issues as he and Audrey, Jeff sees Brad in a whole new light and their friendship is sealed. Meanwhile, Russell discovers the young woman he's dating might be his daughter.