Ben (Rick Gonzalez) would like to introduce Nina (Jenny Wade) to Sam (Bret Harrison) and Sock (Tyler Labine), but he's concerned they won't accept her because she's a demon.

Andi (Missy Peregrym) discovers Sock has created a fake employee at the Work Bench to double his salary, but when he refuses to fix the situation the two go head-to-head in a battle of wits.

Meanwhile, The Devil (Ray Wise) tells Sam he must send a prizefighter from the fifties (guest star Erik Palladino, "ER") back to hell by getting in the ring with him and knocking him out.