Sam (Bret Harrison) must trap a thrill-seeking couple, Holly (guest star Mercedes McNab) and Kit (guest star Craig Stanghetta), who engineer fatal car crashes to keep their relationship fresh and exciting.
Meanwhile, Sam meets a cute new girl named Taylor (guest star Pascale Hutton) and wants to ask her out but becomes suspicious after the Devil (Ray Wise) pushes him to make a move and offers inside tips on her life.