It's college fair day in Rosewood and attendance is optional. Spencer (who attended the college fair last year) spends the better part of the day packing up Ian's things before Melissa returns to Rosewood. Toby finds his yearbook and together they decipher that Ian, Jason and Garrett were all friends and a part of a made up club, "The NAT Club" based on a Latin phrase meaning "we see all".
Hanna is trying to play nice with her future stepsister but in her frustration she embarrasses Kate and quickly makes Kate her nemesis. Meanwhile, Spencer and Emily have told Aria about the creepy sleeping pictures Jason had of her in his dark room, but when she confronts him he explains to Aria that it was a roll of pictures he found in Ali's things. He planned on giving it to her as a gift. Aria buys his explanation. Spencer, seeing that Aria is not listening to her advice to stay away from Jason, goes to Ezra and tells him that he's dangerous. Ezra stops Aria from going into Jason's house and steps up for the sake of their relationship declaring that it's time to tell her parents about them. Little does he know Ella spotted Ezra and Spencer together earlier - and was not pleased.
"A" has determined that Emily is the weakest link and insists that it's time she breaks. She harasses Emily to the breaking point, crashing Emily's massage appointment by discreetly massaging Emily before the masseuse starts! About to break, Emily goes to call Anne Sullivan but gets an "A" text. She ultimately goes to the girls for emotional support and they discuss Garrett, Jason, Ian and the NAT club. They think "A" could be a group of people who have been stalking them together.