Riley (Jennifer Love Hewitt) discovers the "client list" has been stolen and she must find out who took it before her secret life is exposed. Meanwhile, Evan's (Colin Egglesfield) investigation into Carlyle (Johnathon Schaech) reveals that Nikki (Laura Leigh) used to be his employee, putting Evan one step closer to Riley's hidden life. Dale (Greg Grunberg) and Lacey (Rebecca Field) get news that could accelerate their plans to have a family of their own. Derek (Rob Mayes) asks Selena (Alicia Lagano) to make a commitment in their relationship, but Selena isn't sure she's ready. Riley's gambling client, Jimmy (Marcus Coloma), crosses the line when he tracks down Riley at home and runs into Kyle (Brian Hallisay).