The Little Liars visit Spencer at Radley, but are unable to convince her that the body she saw wasn't Toby's. Emily has an idea, though. Perhaps if she can take a picture of the body, they can prove to Spencer they are right. Hanna and Aria are skeptical at first, but they go with Emily and sneak into the morgue. The girls discover a Halloween mask over the body's face; it isn't Toby. Unfortunately, later, Pam tells Emily that another dead body was found in the woods in the same spot where Spencer said she saw Toby.
Aria offers to pick up Malcolm from karate class, but when she arrives, she discovers that "A" already picked him up. She sees a black hoodie lead him through the carnival. Eventually she finds Malcolm safe and sound, but when she asks him who took him, he replies, "She said her name was Alison." Elsewhere, Jamie gets accused of stealing the church bell and is fired from the restoration project. After Hanna tells Caleb about his dad also taking money from the church collection box, Caleb tells Jamie to get out of his life. Unfortunately, after he does, Hanna learns that "A" set Jamie up.
Meanwhile, back at Radley, Spencer finds out Wren helped CeCe see Mona while she was there. Plus, she discovers a board game Mona used to play and learns it also doubles as a map to sneak out. And at the end of the episode, we see Spencer with... a black hoodie!