Spencer freaks out when she discovers she missed the early admission deadline for her dream college. With everything going on with "A," she feels her studies have been neglected. But when she learns that CeCe knows someone in the admissions office and that he'll be at an upcoming party, Spencer begs CeCe to let her tag along. CeCe agrees, so both Aria and Spencer plan to attend the party with her.
Elsewhere, Hanna sees Caleb again. When she speaks to him in the hall at school, she immediately gets a text from "A" demanding that she be at the Apple Rose Grill that night. And if doesn't come alone, Caleb will pay. Imagine Hanna's surprise when she arrives and Caleb is there! He tells her he actually sent the message and he knows something is up. She spills about the new "A" and the two secretly reunite.
The party Aria, Spencer and CeCe go to ends up at Noel Kahn's cabin. Aria's shocked when they receive stamps on their arms before walking in. It's the same stamp they saw on Maya's arm! Once they're inside, Aria and Spencer play a brutal game of "Truth" with Noel and Jenna.
Meanwhile, Aria meets Ezra's little brother, Wesley. He lets it slip to Aria that Ezra got Maggie, his high school girlfriend. The police now have a court order to take a sample of Hanna's blood to see if it's a match for the blood on Ali's bracelet. And Emily sees the photos and videos on Maya's website.