Earl was helping Catalina wax a co-worker's mustache and it took him back to number 92 on his list, "Made Fun of Maggie Lester." Earl remembered when he was in junior high school and he made fun of the new girl for having a mustache. He called her Maggie P.I. in front of everybody in his class.
Earl found Maggie in the phone book and paid her a visit. He talked about his list and explained that she was on it. He also found out that Maggie had become successful while working for a traveling circus. She explained that Earl didn't need to do anything more and she had forgiven him and he was allowed to cross her off his list.
Randy and Earl discovered that Maggie lived in a freak town where all the carnie folk live when it's not carnival season. They were learning about all types of different people. Earl and Randy hung out with a boy with lobster hands, a dwarf, and a man with a horn in his head. The tallest man of the freak show taught the two guys about the stock market.
Joy and Darnell met her court-appointed lawyer, who happened to be a deaf woman. Joy was not comfortable with Ruby Whitlow representing her. Ruby threatened to leave Joy and have her represent her own case. Joy thought that would be a great idea.
While hanging out with the freak show, Earl was reminded of the time when he was younger and was forced to take off his shirt at the pool and the kids made fun of his hairy nipples. He decided to confront the swim coach who made him take off his shirt.
Joy went back to Ruby to ask her take the case. She apologized for being so insensitive before. Joy also informed Ruby that she was going to start giving her the utmost respect. But when Ruby started to talk, Joy busted up laughing and once again Joy almost lost her lawyer.
Earl wanted to show he wasn't ashamed of his hairy nipples so decided to go back to the swimming pool and jump off the diving board with his shirt off. He almost chickened out, but his freak-show friends showed up to give him support. Earl felt better and he jumped off the diving board.