The team is called out to Rancho Rosa to investigate a double homicide. Selby and Jana Vickers were found in their car, both with two bullet wounds to the chest, dressed for Selby's fifteenth high school reunion party. The investigation begins at the reunion check-in. Lisbon and Jane deliver the news about the Vickers to Willa Brock the reunion chair. She reveals Selby's horrible prank that got him expelled in high school. Selby dragged a classmate, Derek Logan, into the girl's locker room, blind folded, stripped him naked, hog tied him and snapped pictures of the incident and posted them all over the school. As the investigation unfolds the team discovers that Selby's wife Jana was a mail order bride for a guy named Terence Badali. Terence wanted the forty thousand dollars it cost him to get Jana to the US from Poland. It is discovered that Selby had an accomplice during the prank in high school that got him expelled, Willa Brock. Selby was going to black mail Willa for the money he owed Terence knowing that her career could not handle that kind of scandal as her talk show was about to go national. Rigsby pretends he's Derek Logan and lures Willa into a trap where she confesses her involvement in the prank and the murder of Selby and Jana Vickers.