Our firm loses an account and so needs to let an employee go. Gordon Lewis, partner at Lewis, Roberts & Roberts, thinks that the way to decide whether to fire someone from Accounts or someone from Creatives is to play each other at a game of Sixteen-Inch Softball. Ten years ago, Simon played the game of his life in the Annual Accounts vs. Creatives 16-inch Softball Game, which is why he's enthusiastic about Gordon Lewis' bet. However, he reveals to Zach that he only played so well ten years ago because he was high. Meanwhile, Sydney tries too hard to make Andrew's girlfriend Nancy like her after Andrew tells her about the kiss they shared. Zach talks Simon into playing for the Creatives team, and when Simon receives a muscle relaxant for a pulled back muscle, he imagines he hits the ball just like he did that legendary time ten years ago, but really he’s just very high and is running through the bases backwards.