When Lacey (Rebecca Field) gets attacked by a man breaking into Riley's home, both Riley (Jennifer Love Hewitt) and Kyle (Brian Hallisay) feel responsible. Riley goes on a mission to find out the identity of the man who broke into her home. When Evan's (Colin Egglesfield) investigation with the police is moving too slow, Riley turns to Georgia (Loretta Devine) for help. Meanwhile, Selena (Alicia Lagano) discovers a secret about Nikki (Laura Leigh) and Derek (Rob Mayes). Riley helps her client, Ben Miller (Adam Mayfield), calm his nerves before he goes out on a date with the girl of his dreams.