Selena (Alicia Lagano) doesn't trust Riley's (Jennifer Love Hewitt) new hire, Nikki (Laura Leigh), and Riley tries to keep the peace and some stability in the wake of all the new changes. We get a glimpse into Nikki's life before The Rub of Sugarland when Riley meets her ex-boss, Greg Carlye (Johnathon Schaech), who runs a strip club. Meanwhile Riley discovers that Derek (Rob Mayes) has been keeping a secret of his own that jeopardizes the Rub of Sugarland. Riley wisely decides that Derek's secret can be used as a valuable business opportunity. Riley must decide whether she wants Katie (Cassidy Guetersloh) and Travis (Tyler Champagne) visiting Kyle (Brian Hallisay) in jail. Riley and Evan (Colin Egglesfield) struggle to find time with each other. Riley receives an unusual request from one of her clients, a pro football player (Trevor Donovan) who likes to test his boundaries.