WHAT'S HOT?
Home > Movie > I > Idlewild > Reviews

Idlewild Reviews

Idlewild

Overview


Genre :

Drama, Musical

Release Date :

August 25, 2006 (Wide)

MPAA Rating :

R

Director :

Bryan Barber

Starring :

Andre Benjamin, Antwan Andre Patton, Paula Patton, Terrence Howard, Patti LaBelle, Ving Rhames

REVIEWS RATE:  Critics  Nothing's perfect, but it's worth seeing.    Readers  Be the 1st!

2 of 5

“..while it's visually inventive, the story's too trite and clich?d to be meaningful..”
by Rich Cline [Shadows on the Wall]
Review rate : A-

“..madly soulful and enjoyable period musical romance..”
by Owen Gleiberman [Entertainment Weekly]
“..grows more conventional and slack as it rolls on..”
by Michael Atkinson [Village Voice]
2 of 4

“..collapses under a disappointing composite of cliches..”
by Elizabeth Weitzman [New York Daily News]
2.5 of 4

“..Bryan Barber's mostly entertaining but erratic pastiche of Thirties-era..”
by Tim Knight [Reel]
“..an entertaining mess..”
by Kirk Honeycutt [The Hollywood Reporter]
“..a middling musical mishmash that can't keep a beat..”
by Nick Schager [Slant Magazine]
3 of 4
Reviewed by Sid Smith [Chicago Tribune]
3 of 5
Reviewed by Andrea Chase [Killer Movie Reviews]
2.5 of 4
Reviewed by Duane Dudek [The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel]
2 of 4
Reviewed by Wesley Morris [Boston Globe]
Reviewed by Ann Powers [Los Angeles Times]
Reviewed by Bill Muller [The Arizona Republic]
Reviewed by Barry Paris [Pittsburgh Post-Gazette]

Reader's Reviews


Screen Name
Rate This Movie
Please Enter   
Comment
 
 
 
RSS
FB
Twitter

LATEST REVIEWS

ALL THINGS FALL APART :

“..it's filled with heart and family and it's just a great drama that will make you laugh, cry and all those feelings in between..”
by Brian Morton [Rogue Cinema]

SAFE HOUSE :

“..together, Washington and Reynolds make a watchable team - and make the occasionally exciting "Safe House" more watchable than it deserves to be..”
by Marshall Fine [Hollywood & Fine]

JOURNEY 2: THE MYSTERIOUS ISLAND :

“..this affable adventure is in on the joke..”
by Nick De Semlyen [Empire Magazine]

THE VOW :

“..every composition and cut is made with its calculated effect readily evident..”
by Todd McCarthy [Hollywood Reporter]

IN DARKNESS :

“..it is suspenseful, horrifying and at times intensely moving..”
by A.O. Scott [New York Times]

RETURN :

“..firmly in the unassuming indie vein, Return treads lightly and leaves little imprint..”
by Nick Pinkerton [Village Voice]

KILL LIST :

“..this is one smart film from someone with a singular voice who knows their craft..”
by David Edwards [Daily Mirror]

THE INNKEEPERS :

“..a brilliantly plotted piece of location-centric, minimalist horror..”
by Jesse Cataldo [Slant Magazine]

BIG MIRACLE :

“..your heart will also go out to the cast, stuck even more pitiably in syrupy manufactured crises..”
by Melissa Anderson [Village Voice]

W.E. :

“..watch W.E. as if flipping through a stack of glossy mags with a pal, oohing and aahing about stuff without caring a fiddle-dee-dee about substance..”
by Lisa Schwarzbaum [Entertainment Weekly]