After Lydia (Krista Allen) forces him to give Jimmy (Nathaniel Buzolic) the night off, Nate (Josh Zuckerman) hires a temporary bartender named Timmy (guest star Justin Deeley), who shares an uncanny resemblance to Jimmy. Impressed with his skills and new money-making potential, Nate hires Timmy for the remainder of the week. Not happy with Timmy moving in on his territory, and in on his friendship with Nate, Jimmy suggests a bartending duel to determine who is the best man for the job - and who is the best friend for Nate.