After Nate (Josh Zuckerman) suggests they may not be taking their relationship seriously, Lydia (Krista Allen) and Jimmy (Nathaniel Buzolic) decide to prove him wrong by going on a date - in public. Meanwhile, Jimmy calls Nate out for his own lackluster dating style, prompting him to go on a date with a notorious cougar he meets at the restaurant. Elsewhere, Atticus (Jay Ali) prepares for his own perfect evening enjoying the equinox with Sam (Emma Fitzpatrick). Finally, things take an uncomfortable turn when Lydia and Jimmy run into Nate on his date with Pepper Spinner (Denise Richards), who happens to be Lydia's former archrival.