AceShowbiz - Back in 2019, Blake Horstmann made headlines when he posted online some text messages between him and Caelynn Miller-Keyes in which they arranged a hookup at Stagecoach one night after he had sex with fellow contestant Kristina Schulman.
The back-and-forth between Blake and Caelynn started after Caelynn claimed that their relationship was more serious than Blake said. On "BiP", she claimed in tears that Blake asked her to keep their tryst a secret and called it a "mistake." To debunk her remarks, Blake posted on Instagram their texts after the episode aired. The text revealed that it was actually Caelynn who suggested for the hookup and she was equally concerned about people finding out.