| 2015 |
W |
- |
- |
- |
| 2015 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
Kevin Owens |
| 2015 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
Brock Lesnar |
| 2015 |
N |
Rivalry of the Year |
- |
Rusev |
| 2014 |
W |
Match of the Year |
- |
Dolph Ziggler, Big Show, Erick Rowan, Ryback |
| 2014 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
Bray Wyatt |
| 2014 |
N |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2014 |
N |
Rivalry of the Year |
- |
Brock Lesnar |
| 2013 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
The Rock |
| 2013 |
N |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2013 |
N |
Couple of the Year |
- |
Nikki Bella |
| 2012 |
W |
Kiss of the Year |
- |
AJ Lee |
| 2012 |
W |
Insult of the Year |
- |
Dolph Ziggler, Vickie Guerrero: |
| 2012 |
W |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2012 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
The Rock |
| 2011 |
W |
Game Changer of the Year |
- |
The Rock |
| 2011 |
W |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2010 |
W |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2010 |
W |
Holy %&@*# Move of the Year |
Sends Batista through the stage with an Attitude Adjustment |
- |
| 2010 |
N |
WWE Universe Fan Reaction of the Year |
Kid shocked after John Cena lost to Wade Barrett at the Hell In A Cell 2010 PPV |
- |
| 2010 |
N |
WWE Moment of the Year |
- |
Wade Barrett |
| 2009 |
W |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2009 |
N |
Extreme Moment of the Year |
- |
Big Show |
| 2009 |
N |
Match of the Year |
- |
Randy Orton |
| 2008 |
N |
Superstar of the Year |
- |
- |
| 2008 |
N |
"OMG!" Moment of the Year |
Returns at the Royal Rumble |
- |
