Alex, Mason, Max, and Justin search for Juliet but Alex and Justin get a surprise when they find out Juliet and Mason dated over 300 years ago. After Mason says accidently that he loves Juliet, Alex is left heartbroken and Justin is angry with him for breaking her heart. Earlier Mason gives Alex a magic necklace to tell if the wearer loves the person who put it on them so he convinces her to let them go back were they defeated the mummy (unwraping the toilet paper) to find the necklace she threw. Justin tells Mason to stay away from her, but he and Justin get in a fight, which leads to Juliet fighting and biting Mason and Mason scratching Juliet (it is revealed when a werewolf scratches a vampire, it takes away their power, and reveals their actual age, and when a vampire bites a werewolf, it transforms them into a wolf permanently). Max finds the necklace and it turns out Mason really did love Alex. She didn't want him to go but he said it was too late for them and she'd never be safe. Juliet turns really old and insits to leave but Justin keeps fighting back and tells her he doesn't matter how old she is. They promise to keep each other in their hearts forever. In the end, Juliet leaves Justin, and Mason leaves Alex. Justin is heartbroken since he just found her and he's losing her again.
