A highly competitive album sales race between Sabrina Carpenter and Travis Scott has sparked controversy, with Scott's label alleging irregularities in the data tracking process.
- Sep 7, 2024
AceShowbiz - The music industry is no stranger to drama, but the recent clash between Sabrina Carpenter and Travis Scott (II) over the No. 1 spot on Billboard's album charts has reached new heights of contention and conspiracy. What started as a close race has now transformed into a whirlwind of accusations, secret letters, and alleged data tampering.
The tension began when Sabrina Carpenter's "Short N' Sweet" narrowly ousted Travis Scott's re-released "Days Before Rodeo" by about 1,000 units, according to the final results on September 3, as reported by Bloomberg. This close margin has left Scott's camp, specifically his label Cactus Jack, feeling wronged.
An explosive Vulture article claims that Cactus Jack sent an alleged letter to Billboard and Luminate, the company that tracks chart data, accusing them of an "unreliable and incomplete" data process that unfairly cost Scott his debut at the top. They argued that approximately 1,000 units of "Days Before Rodeo" were reported late due to a delay, which allegedly skewed the final tally in Carpenter's favor.
The letter further contends that Luminate and Billboard gave disproportionate weight to Sabrina's indie record sales. This, they claim, was supposed to be rectified by the start of 2024. "It clearly bumped Sabrina's final number of units just above Travis by almost the exact amount of units we erroneously 'lost,' " the letter reportedly reads.
Compounding the controversy, Cactus Jack pointed out that the Luminate employee handling the issue is a former worker at Sabrina's label, Island Records, implying potential bias.
Fans of Travis Scott did not take these claims lightly. According to In The Mix, video evidence surfaced on social media platform X (formerly Twitter), hinting at possible tampering with the Billboard results. The footage allegedly showed Scott in the lead until a recount adjusted the numbers to favor Carpenter, sparking outrage among La Flame's fervent supporters.
While Billboard and Luminate have maintained their processes and methodologies as sound, the uproar among fans and the back-and-forth between the artists' camps reveal a deeply competitive and occasionally contentious music industry landscape. Both Carpenter and Scott employed various strategies to boost sales, such as releasing new album versions and bonus tracks, adding fuel to the fire.
In the end, whether this is a case of genuine procedural error, potential favoritism, or merely an intense chart battle, it perfectly encapsulates the fierce competition that comes with achieving the prestigious No. 1 spot on Billboard. As this story develops, fans and industry watchers alike will be keenly observing every twist and turn.