Mike and Molly are both looking the perfect gift for each other for their first Christmas together. Molly is a great gift-giver and has deftly picked up the hint that Mike wants a bomber jacket so that's what she buys him. Mike, on the other hand, is clueless, and seems incapable of hearing any of Molly's hints. Furthermore, he doesn't want to send the wrong message (e.g., jewelry sets the bar too high). Despite Carl's help, Mike can't find the right gift and ends up buying a bomber jacket for himself. Now Molly has to buy him a new gift at the last minute and she's very stressed. Mike, on the other hand, has no idea what to get Molly until he talks to Samuel. Samuel reassures Mike that his love for Molly is the greatest gift he can give. At Mike's mother's house, they exchange gifts -- Molly got Mike an X-box, which he loves and Mike got Molly an expensive diamond bracelet. Molly loves the bracelet but knows Mike can't afford it. As they fight about taking it back, they both end up saying "I love you" for the first time. It really is the best gift of all.