Jay-Z's lawsuit against attorney Tony Buzbee moves to New York federal court. Judge denies dismissal, case tied to dismissed assault allegations and extortio...
- April 1, 2026
AceShowbiz - Jay-Z has secured a significant legal development as his ongoing lawsuit involving attorney Tony Buzbee will now proceed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. This follows a recent ruling by a federal judge who denied a motion to dismiss the case but transferred the venue from Alabama to New York.
The decision, announced on Tuesday, March 31, came from U.S. District Judge Terry Moorer. Judge Moorer rejected Buzbee’s request to dismiss the lawsuit on jurisdictional grounds but agreed that the matter was better suited to be heard in New York rather than Alabama.
The lawsuit originates from allegations tied to a dismissed sexual assault case against the Roc Nation founder. Jay-Z has consistently denied the accusations, calling them false and asserting that they were part of an effort to extort money from him. The case also involves a Jane Doe accuser and attorney David Fortney.
Buzbee argued that the Alabama court lacked proper jurisdiction, noting that although the Jane Doe plaintiff resides in Alabama, the alleged incident took place in New York. Judge Moorer concurred that New York was the appropriate forum but did not dismiss the lawsuit outright, stating in court documents that the case should be transferred “in the interest of justice.”
The court documents specify that motions to dismiss filed by all defendants, along with motions to proceed under a pseudonym, remain pending and will be resolved by the New York court. This venue change could have important implications, including the potential loss of anonymity for the accuser, who is still named as a defendant in Jay-Z’s lawsuit.
The underlying events trace back to a now-withdrawn sexual assault lawsuit in which the Jane Doe accused both Jay-Z and Sean “Diddy” Combs of assaulting her at an after-party linked to the 2000 MTV Video Music Awards. The accuser claimed she was 13 years old at the time. The lawsuit was later dismissed with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled, though no public explanation for the dismissal was provided.
After that dismissal, Jay-Z filed a countersuit accusing the woman of fabricating the allegations in order to obtain a financial settlement. Tony Buzbee has denied these claims, insisting his client stands by her account and asserting that Jay-Z’s lawsuit lacks legal merit. Additionally, Jay-Z’s legal team has accused Buzbee of encouraging the original lawsuit despite knowing it was based on falsehoods.
Previously, in 2024, Jay-Z initiated a separate legal action in Los Angeles against Buzbee, accusing him of defamation and extortion. That case was dismissed, but Jay-Z has appealed the ruling.
With the case now shifted to New York, the next steps will be determined by a new judge who will address the pending motions, including the requests to dismiss and those concerning the accuser’s anonymity. The legal proceedings are expected to continue, maintaining the high-profile nature of this dispute.