Landman S1 review: Taylor Sheridan's refreshing oil drama starring Billy Bob Thornton. Praised for humor & stakes, but flawed by Ainsley's hypersexualization...
- November 12, 2025
AceShowbiz - While many of Taylor Sheridan's series often experience a rocky start before finding their rhythm, the debut season of Landman was largely hailed as a refreshing departure. The show delved into the intricacies of the West Texas oil business, masterfully portrayed through the eyes of Billy Bob Thornton's industry veteran, Tommy Norris. Season 1 stood out as arguably the funniest in Sheridan's lineup, balancing its humor with genuine stakes for its characters. However, Landman season 1 wasn't without its significant flaws, including the increasingly off-putting hypersexualization of Tommy's 17-year-old daughter, Ainsley (Michelle Randolph), and Ali Larter's portrayal of Angela Norris, which often felt like an over-the-top caricature.
One of the most glaring missteps in the first season was the egregious underutilization of a talent like Demi Moore, who was relegated to minimal screentime and dialogue. Heading into Landman season 2, the lingering story threads from the previous season certainly paved the way for potential improvements in both storytelling and character development. With the death of Jon Hamm's Monty, Moore's Cami Miller was poised for a more substantial position of power, and Ainsley's high school graduation promised more mature and investable storylines. Yet, based on the first two episodes provided for review, Landman season 2 finds itself on surprisingly rocky ground from the outset.
The good news is that Demi Moore's expanded role is indeed a welcome and much-needed change from the show's initial outing. In season 1, Moore's character felt largely like arm candy for Monty, with her most involved work being concern for his declining health. This was particularly puzzling given her recent onscreen resurgence in projects like Feud: Capote vs. The Swans and her Oscar-nominated turn in The Substance. Whether Sheridan always intended a proper arc for her character or learned from season 1 critiques, it is genuinely refreshing to see Moore finally given a proper spotlight in Landman season 2, allowing her to deliver a more nuanced performance.
However, this positive development for Cami Miller is unfortunately overshadowed by the stagnation or regression of many other key characters. Several storylines appear stuck in tired patterns, failing to advance or evolve in a meaningful way. The promise of more mature narratives for characters like Ainsley seems to be largely unfulfilled in these early episodes, undermining the potential for growth established in the first season. This unevenness creates a distinctly mixed bag scenario, where one significant improvement is counterbalanced by a lack of progress, or even a step backward, in other crucial areas of the series.
Ultimately, while Landman season 1 was praised for breaking the mold of Sheridan's often-rocky debut seasons, season 2, in its initial episodes, risks falling back into those familiar patterns of uneven storytelling. The series faces the challenge of fully leveraging Demi Moore's deservedly expanded role to elevate the entire show, rather than letting other unresolved issues and character regressions drag down its otherwise promising premise.