In rural Indiana, the Daly family wrestles with the mysterious return of Lauren, a daughter kidnapped over a decade ago while her brother Noah was supposed to be watching her. Their uncle, Tommy, then a sheriff's deputy, was unable to find her, and her case remained unresolved.

Upon her return, Lauren is mute, and both she and the whole family struggle to become comfortable with the unexpected reunion. Tommy relaunches his investigation in hopes of bringing some resolution to the family.