In a ploy to get a new bike, Gabe blames Charlie for opening the garage door and allowing for his bike to get stolen, when in reality, he sold his old bike. In the meantime, Teddy has to shoot a scene of an important moment in her life, so she chooses when Amy and Bob told her they were expecting Charlie. When Amy gets too involved behind-the-scenes, Teddy accidentally lets it slip how she really felt that day.