After discovering that Spencer was dating them both, Teddy and Skylar (the "other girl") decide to mend their broken hearts by producing a mean music video about him. But when he apologizes to Teddy, she decides not to upload it for the world to see. Meanwhile, PJ and Gabe are sick of sharing a room, so when Gabe discovers that Mrs. Dabney has an extra room, he decides to sneak into it every night. Amy, on the other hand, gets busy utilizing her gym's free babysitting services to spend time at the spa down the street.