Ned's college radio show brings an old radio prank to life and a ghost that died from it, when they discover the prank was a script that was something that actually happened 8 years before word for word. The old DJ had a set up where a husband called his wife to break up with her with the promise of winning a Bahamas vacation. Ned discovers this when strange things start happening to the station and the actual wife from the original prank comes to yell at them. Melinda finds her husband, Jack, who originally made the call. Jack claims his wife, Maggie, knew it was a prank but she was already riddled with doubts about his fidelity. She wouldn't let up in asking him who the other woman was and he finally said he was leaving her for a coworker from his office, Daisy. Jack insists he was faithful but when Melinda talks to him she discovers that he is indeed married to Daisy, having divorced his first wife, Maggie. He says that they did go on the trip but their marriage was never the same after that call. Melinda suspects the ghost is the former fiancee of Daisy's who disappeared without a trace. Daisy insists she never cheated on her fiancee, Bruce, and only got together with Jack months and months later. Upon futher prodding, Melinda discovers that Maggie was convinced something was going on with Jack and Daisy so when he named Daisy on the radio show, it only confirmed her suspicions. She called Bruce to let him know that Jack and Daisy were on their way to a Bahamas vacation so he immediately got in his car to try and stop them. The roads were trecherous and his car went off a cliff into the water. Melinda crosses Bruce over after straigtening out the misunderstanding.