In a devoutly Catholic community, a teenage girl’s life takes an unimaginable turn in this poignant and darkly comedic drama from writer-director Beth Schacter. Mary, a sheltered and earnest high school student, finds her faith and future thrown into chaos when she becomes convinced she is experiencing a modern-day immaculate conception, despite being a virgin. As word of her claim spreads like wildfire, she becomes a reluctant lightning rod, drawing both fervent believers and harsh skeptics into her orbit, including her bewildered family and a local priest grappling with his own doubts. The film navigates the delicate balance between earnest drama and sharp satire, exploring the collision of unwavering faith, social pressure, and the turbulent search for identity. As Mary’s conviction is tested from all sides, she must confront what she truly believes about herself, her community, and the mysterious circumstances that have made her the center of a modern miracle or a monumental scandal.