After years of prioritizing her stand-up career over romance, comedian Andrea Singer, played by Iliza Shlesinger, finally meets a man who seems too good to be true. Dennis, portrayed by Ryan Hansen, is charming, supportive, and appears to be the perfect, drama-free boyfriend she never knew she wanted. Encouraged by her skeptical best friend Margot, Margaret Cho, Andrea allows herself to fall for his seemingly ideal life. However, as their relationship deepens, small inconsistencies in Dennis's stories begin to surface, leading Andrea down a rabbit hole of doubt. What starts as a modern romantic comedy quickly spirals into a hilarious and tense investigation, as Andrea must use her wit to uncover the truth about the man she's dating. This sharp, R-rated film, written by Iliza Shlesinger and directed by Kimmy Gatewood, blends laugh-out-loud humor with moments of genuine suspense, exploring the fine line between trusting your heart and listening to your gut when a fairytale romance starts to show its cracks.