Best friends Mitch (Mark-Paul Gosselaar) and Russell (Tone Bell) don't shy away from discussing touchy subjects, including race, money, sex, marriage and, yes, even porn. So when Russell recognizes Mitch's new babysitter, Kimberly, from a porno, he doesn't hesitate to bring it up. But Mitch's wife, Tracy (Vanessa Lachey), is desperate for a night out and Mitch doesn't want to ruin that if he doesn't have to. She's finally found a babysitter she trusts and the group has tickets to see Jay Z.
While hiding from Tracy and Russell's wife Angie (Bresha Webb), Mitch and Russell watch the film to confirm that it's Kimberly but come away unsure. Russell advises Mitch to keep his mouth shut, but Mitch proves unable to do so and blurts out the truth just as he, Tracy, Russell and Angie are headed to the concert. Tracy and Angie then watch the porn and compare it to Kimberly's Facebook profile. Unfortunately, Kimberly catches them and storms off, leaving the group with no babysitter and no Jay Z.
