After quitting her job a week ago, Audrey grows very restless as she has completed every item on her "to-do" list and decides to clean out their storage unit in the basement. After cleaning it out, she comes across her grandmother's cookie recipe and after a full day of baking and soul-searching decides she wants to start a cookie business. Audrey is further buoyed by Jen and Adam who come over after smoking some old pot (unbeknownst to Audrey) they found, and rave about how fantastic Audrey's cookies are. Jeff pretends to be supportive at first but Audrey soon realizes he thinks it is a bad idea and is furious at him for not being on board. In an attempt to show that he believes in her, Jeff signs the lease on a retail space so Audrey can start her new venture only to find she has already realized her decision was a bit rash and she does not want to start a cookie business after all. Meanwhile, Timmy is excited about having a girlfriend and tries desperately to partake in all "the guy talk" at the diner.