The rock star surfaces once again in the drama of 'Vanderpump Rules' as Scheana stands by her claims of a past fling with the musician during the season 11 reunion.
- May 22, 2024
AceShowbiz - During the second part of the "Vanderpump Rules" season 11 reunion, which aired on May 21, an unexpected topic of conversation reignited past rumors involving A-list musician John Mayer. Host Andy Cohen's discussion with newcomer Jo Wenberg about her dating life spiraled into a buzzworthy moment when Scheana Shay reaffirmed her alleged romantic past with Mayer.
The conversation began when Jo, responding to a question about new romantic interests, quipped she would date football star Aaron Rodgers. Both Ariana Madix and Cohen immediately discouraged the notion, criticizing Rodgers' controversial stances. As Jo humorously proposed John Mayer as another option, Scheana Shay sparked intrigue among fans by declaring, "Been there, done that."
Scheana's candid confessions regarding her supposed relationship with Mayer have been a recurring theme. Earlier in 2024, she addressed their rendezvous during an episode of her "Scheananigans" podcast. Despite an insider close to Mayer asserting that the two "never hooked up," Shay stood firm on her version of events. She emphasized, "I'm sure John doesn't love being a story line on 'Vanderpump Rules', but where did he deny this?"
Scheana has maintained her narrative since 2008, recounting the sequence of events that led to their connection. She claimed that while waitressing at the Grand Havana Room in Beverly Hills, she met Mayer and his then-girlfriend, Jennifer Aniston. Her involvement allegedly included afterparties and a notable interaction where Mayer sought her number following his split from Aniston.
Drawing more skepticism and eventual employment consequences, Scheana recounted getting fired due to fraternizing with Mayer, whom she noted was a member at a different branch of the cigar club. Adding another layer of complexity, Shay suggested their brief relationship even evolved into a "throuple" involving Stacie Adams, recognizable from "The Hills" as "Stacie the Bartender".
Despite consistent allegations, Mayer has never publicly addressed Scheana's claims. The renewed discussion has stirred mixed reactions among fans and insiders alike, leaving Mayer's perspective noticeably absent from the narrative. As the Bravo series continues to intertwine with real-life controversies, the reemergence of Scheana's stories reinforces the blurred lines between reality TV and celebrity affiliations.
The third part of the "Vanderpump Rules" season 11 reunion promises more drama and revelations. Fans can catch the episode on Bravo on Tuesday, May 28, or stream it on Peacock the following day.
