Sure, Peter Burke can ride a horse and handle a high-end sports car, but can he date? That's the question when he, Neal and Jones go undercover as millionaires in a bachelor auction to pursue Selena Thomas, a serial bride who seems to be marrying and killing rich men. Peter's a little rusty, but with some coaching from Elizabeth he catches the sexy Black Widow's attention. And with some fancy footwork on their date, Peter is able to plant a bug at Selena's house while avoiding her amorous advances. Yup, Peter's still got it.
Meanwhile, the team soon learns that Selena has a partner in crime. Which means that if they want to find the other half of this murderous duo, Peter's going to have to keep wooing this seductive man-eater, much to his, and Elizabeth's, chagrin. Hoping to catch a glance at Selena's cell phone, Peter sets a second date. But the sultry Selena has other plans in mind: she wants to go back to Peter's place, and she won't take no for an answer. It looks like Burke the babe magnet may have gotten in over his head..