Ryan overhears Amanda's boyfriend making other plans for lunch, so he and True decide to follow him only to discover he's cheating on her. True decides it's best to tell Amanda, which only makes her give True more work. Meanwhile, Max enlists Lulu to help his accountant with an audit, and Lulu thinks he may be Santa Claus after observing his striking resemblance to Kris Kringle, not to mention his jolly chuckle, "Jingle Bells" ringtone and North Pole vernacular.