It's Bay and Daphne's birthday week and a lot is going on. First, Daphne has a jarring dream in which she is hearing and Bay is deaf. Once she wakes up, the realization of the situation she's in sinks in. Meanwhile, Melody kicks Regina out of her house where she's been hiding from her daughters for a few days. And Kathryn and John look into getting custody of Daphne.
Regina unsuccessfully tries to reconnect with Daphne and Bay. An upset Daphne even gets in a fight on the basketball court. Emmett tries to help Bay tag a wall, but they are interrupted by the police. Melody discovers Emmett and Bay hanging out and isn't happy about it.
The day before their birthday, John and Kathryn buy Daphne and Bay both used cars. The Kennish family has a small birthday celebration for Daphne and Bay without Regina, but Regina barges in. Regina gives Daphne a birthday present and it helps break the ice between them.
Meanwhile, Emmett gives Daphne a thoughtful present but gives Bay a scarf. It turns out Bay's present isn't a scarf, it's a blindfold! Emmett went back and tagged the wall for Bay. Bay and Emmett decide it's time to tell Daphne about them. However, before Bay can tell Daphne that she's dating Emmett, Daphne reveals that she thinks she's into Emmett. Bay doesn't say anything about her and Emmett.