When Audrey hears that Jeff is planning to meet his softball teammate/friend Brenda after work for a couple of beers, she seizes the opportunity to come along in order to try and bond more with Brenda who has agreed to be their surrogate. However, Audrey quickly modifies their plans into a double date with Brenda and her new girlfriend Becky. At the restaurant, Becky is shocked when Audrey reveals Brenda is planning to be their surrogate, as Brenda had not yet told this news to Becky. Becky breaks up with her, and Brenda comes over to the apartment seeking Jeff for consolation, making Audrey realize and accept that her friendship with Brenda will have to evolve over time. Russell takes his date Jessica to a Criss Angel magic show to impress her, only to have Criss make her "disappear" as part of the show, and not return. Meanwhile, Timmy needs Russell to fill out his evaluation in order to receive his raise, so he agrees to babysit Jessica's unruly 10 year old son Leland while they are at the show. Jennifer is using Joe, the new super to fix everything in their apartment. Adam, a bit jealous, tries to prove he can do stuff around the house only to reconfirm that he cannot when he gets knocked out trying to install a new showerhead.