Audrey and Jeff go on a double date with Brad and Jackie, during which Jackie helps himself to Jeff's entree before he is finished with it. Jeff, who despises sharing food, has a huge problem with this, but Audrey, who is becoming close friends with a sensitive Jackie, demands that he keep quiet about it to avoid hurting Jackie's feelings. Audrey sets up a second double date, and to protect his meal Jeff sets up a scenario where it would be impossible for Jackie to share his dinner but is ultimately foiled. Unable to restrain himself any longer, Jeff makes a comment that sets off an unfortunate sequence of events for Brad. Meanwhile, Russell starts dating a psychiatrist who he feels could really help him get past some mental issues. He can't see her professionally because of their personal relationship, so Russell recruits Timmy to act as him during a consultation with her.