When Jeff keeps falling asleep while watching a movie, Audrey decides to play a prank on him by staging a picture where he's snuggled up with an old afghan with his reading glass dropping off his nose, making him look like an old grandpa. She shares it with Adam and Russell who take great delight in teasing Jeff, but Jeff takes it to heart and declares he's just as young and spry as he ever was. To prove this he invites them to check him out in action at softball, but while at bat he ends up throwing out his back after simply sneezing, proving that he may be older than he thinks. Meanwhile, Adam deals with Jennifer's mood swings after she stops taking the pill.