While everyone around her is making special plans for Valentine's Day, Rita (Nicole Sullivan) questions whether her marriage has lost some of its romance when she and Jay (Richard Ruccolo) decide on an evening of pizza and TV. After a change of heart, Rita plans an elaborate surprise evening for Jay, but it's cut short when Yoda gets sick. After hearing his wife admit that spontaneity may no longer be possible for them, Jay comes up with a plan of his own. Meanwhile, Shannon (Kelly Gould) prepares Yoda (Auggie) for a dog show.