Sam (Bret Harrison) is less than thrilled when Andi's (Missy Peregrym) ex-boyfriend Greg (guest star Colby Johannson) reappears on the scene and asks Andi out on a date. To Sam's shock and dismay, Andi accepts and decides to break up with Sam.

Suspicious about Greg's sudden power of persuasion, Sam investigates and discovers Greg has sold his soul to the Devil (Ray Wise) in order to win back his one true love.