Megan (Joanna Garcia) is upset when Shelby (guest star Sharon Lawrence) tells her that Will (Brian Hallisay) is a playboy who will never commit. Megan finally confronts Shelby and lets out all her anger over being abandoned. As an excuse for Sage (Ashley Newbrough) to spend more time with Luis (guest star Ignacio Serricchio), Rose (Lucy Kate Hale) comes up with the idea of throwing an elaborate charity dinner, complete with a synchronized swim team to tell the story of Cuban refugees. However, the plan backfires when Luis reveals he is not of Cuban descent. Meanwhile, Marco's (Allan Louis) boyfriend Keith (guest star David Monahan) encourages Marco to quit his job and open his own cafe, but they end up arguing about their future together. Charlie (Michael Cassidy) decides to go back to school, but his girlfriend Mandy (guest star Alice Greczyn) turns manipulative when she learns he'll be spending study time with Megan. Finally, Megan is shocked to get a phone call telling her that her sister Lily (Kristina Apgar, who does not appear in the episode) is in jail.