In a dream, Allison "sees' Ariel's new boyfriend, Casey, stalking a man with a gun. The man from her dream turns out to be Earl Sanderson, a murder victim the police are investigating and Ariel is horrified when Allison starts questioning Casey in the murder. It turns out that Casey believes he is reincarnated from a man that Sanderson killed, named Angelo Filipelli. Casey is actually Filipelli's child and Casey's mother had hired Sanderson to kill Filipelli to hide the affair from her husband. Allison and Joe find out that Bridgette has been secretly video taping their clumsy neighbor, Lloyd Darby, and the videos have become an internet sensation. Lloyd tells Joe he's going to sue, but then changes his mind when the publicity from the videos helps him reconnect with a long lost love.